MBA Programs Emphasizing Character Over Credentials

David Brooks
7 Min Read

The evolving nature of business education stands at a crossroads today, with traditional MBA programs facing mounting scrutiny about their relevance in developing tomorrow’s leaders. The conversation around business education has shifted dramatically, moving beyond the quantitative skills that once defined success toward something more fundamental: character development.

The transformation isn’t merely academic. According to a recent Harvard Business Review survey, 67% of employers now rank ethical decision-making and leadership integrity among their top three priorities when hiring business school graduates. This represents a significant shift from just a decade ago when technical expertise and analytical abilities dominated hiring criteria.

What’s driving this change? For one, the spectacular corporate failures of recent years—from Theranos to WeWork—have forced a reckoning about the type of leaders business schools are producing. These case studies in poor judgment weren’t failures of intelligence or technical knowledge but rather catastrophic character deficiencies.

“We’re witnessing the limits of competence without character,” explains Dr. Katherine Klein, Vice Dean for the Wharton Social Impact Initiative. “The most sophisticated financial modeling means nothing without the judgment to use it ethically.”

This realization has sparked innovation across elite business schools. Stanford’s Graduate School of Business has expanded its “Leadership for Society” program, which explicitly focuses on moral reasoning. Meanwhile, INSEAD has introduced a mandatory ethics course called “Business and Society” that comprises nearly 10% of its core curriculum.

The Aspen Institute’s Beyond Grey Pinstripes report indicates these aren’t isolated examples. Between 2019 and 2023, there’s been a 43% increase in MBA coursework focused on ethics, leadership character, and social responsibility across top-ranked programs.

But integrating character development into business education isn’t straightforward. Unlike financial accounting or statistical analysis, virtues like integrity, humility, and courage don’t fit neatly into traditional pedagogy. They require experiential learning, reflection, and practice.

Darden School of Business at the University of Virginia has pioneered this approach with its Olsson Center for Applied Ethics. Students engage in scenario-based learning that places them in ethically complex situations requiring real-time decision-making. The program then uses these experiences as foundations for deeper exploration of character and values.

“We’re trying to create situations of productive discomfort,” says Professor Bobby Parmar, who teaches in the program. “It’s in these moments of ethical tension that students develop the moral muscles they’ll need throughout their careers.”

Critics question whether business schools—institutions deeply embedded in market logic—can authentically teach character. Yale management professor Jeffrey Sonnenfeld acknowledges this tension but sees it differently. “Business schools aren’t just teaching technical skills to maximize profit; they’re preparing stewards of resources and human capital. That inherently involves character.”

Data from McKinsey’s leadership development research supports this view. Their analysis of executive performance across industries shows that leaders with strong character attributes—particularly honesty, accountability, and care for others—deliver 23% higher organizational performance than those who excel solely in competence measures.

The focus on character also responds to changing student expectations. The Graduate Management Admission Council reports that 58% of MBA applicants now prioritize programs with strong ethics components and social impact opportunities, compared to just 31% in 2015.

For Beth Moreau, a second-year MBA candidate at MIT Sloan, this emphasis on character development was decisive in her program choice. “I didn’t want just technical training. I wanted an education that would help me become the kind of leader I’d want to work for.”

The financial services industry, historically focused on credentials and technical skills, has also begun prioritizing character in hiring. Goldman Sachs has restructured its MBA recruitment process to include behavioral assessments designed to evaluate integrity and judgment. JPMorgan Chase has similarly incorporated character-focused case interviews into its selection process.

“Technical skills get you in the door, but character determines how far you’ll go,” explains James Gorman, Morgan Stanley’s CEO. “We’re looking for people who will make the right decisions when no one is watching.”

The pandemic accelerated this transformation. Remote work environments removed many traditional supervision structures, making character traits like self-discipline, honesty, and initiative more visible and valuable than ever before.

The World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs Report predicts that by 2025, the most valued workplace skills will include ethical judgment, accountability, and empathy—all fundamentally character attributes rather than technical competencies.

This doesn’t mean traditional MBA skills are becoming irrelevant. Rather, they’re necessary but insufficient. The future business leader needs both quantitative expertise and moral intelligence—the technical ability to identify what can be done alongside the wisdom to determine what should be done.

As business education continues evolving, the most successful programs will likely be those that integrate character development throughout their curricula rather than treating ethics as a standalone subject. This integrated approach mirrors how ethical decisions actually occur in business—not as isolated moral quandaries but embedded within everyday strategic choices.

For prospective MBA students, this shift offers both opportunity and challenge. The opportunity lies in more holistic development; the challenge in choosing programs that authentically develop character rather than merely paying lip service to ethics.

The stakes couldn’t be higher. As business influence in society continues growing, the character of those leading these institutions becomes increasingly consequential not just for corporate performance but for social well-being.

“In the end,” says Harvard Business School Dean Srikant Datar, “business education is about preparing people who will shape our economic future. Their character will determine whether that future serves the many or just the few.”

Share This Article
David is a business journalist based in New York City. A graduate of the Wharton School, David worked in corporate finance before transitioning to journalism. He specializes in analyzing market trends, reporting on Wall Street, and uncovering stories about startups disrupting traditional industries.
Leave a Comment